References:
Dillon, L.M. (no date). Applied Behavior Analysis: Helping Children with Autism. Retrieved from: http://www.appliedbehavioranalysis.com/ReinforcementSchedules.htm
Loftin, Odom, & Lantz (2007). Social Interactions and Repetitive Motor Behaviors. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 38(6), 1124-1135.
Kay, S., Harchik, A.E., & Luiselli, J.K. Elimination of Drooling by an Adolescent Student with Autism Attending Public High School. Journal of Positive Behavioral Interventions, 8(1), 24-28.
Pennsylvania Department of Education (2006). Pennsylvania Verbal Behavior Project Family Handbook. Administered by Tuscarora Intermediate Unit 11.
Sundberg, M.L & Michael, J. (2001). The Benefits of Skinner's Analysis of Verbal Behavior for Children With Autism. Behavior Modification, 25 (5), 698-724.
Explain the concept of reinforcement. Refer to available research.
Reinforcement is a process used following a desired behavior in order to increase the likelihood of that behavior occurring again. Reinforcement is meant to strengthen the frequency, rate, duration, or intensity of a wanted behavior. B.F. Skinner was the first to articulate the term automatic reinforcement, which is reinforcement that occurs without someone providing it. For example, think of infants and their verbal behaviors. When a typically-developing infant vocalizes, he is automatically reinforcing his behavior since he is able to hear himself sounding similar to mommy or daddy, in turn, increasing the frequency of that type of vocal behavior. Persons, such as Mark Sundberg, went on to develop the concept of Verbal Behavior and use of reinforcements further (Sundberg & Michael, 2001).
There are two types of reinforcement: positive and negative. Both are used to increase the likelihood of the behavior occurring again. In positive reinforcement, something is gained or added to improve the probability of the behavior occurring again. An example would be getting a drink of milk after saying “milk.” In negative reinforcement, something is taken away to increase the desired behavior. An example of negative reinforcement would be a teacher giving one less homework assignment if the class behaves appropriately during the assembly (Pennsylvania Department of Education, 2006).
There are two types of reinforcement: positive and negative. Both are used to increase the likelihood of the behavior occurring again. In positive reinforcement, something is gained or added to improve the probability of the behavior occurring again. An example would be getting a drink of milk after saying “milk.” In negative reinforcement, something is taken away to increase the desired behavior. An example of negative reinforcement would be a teacher giving one less homework assignment if the class behaves appropriately during the assembly (Pennsylvania Department of Education, 2006).
I read an article recently in which a 17 year old male who had diagnoses of Autism and MR excessively drooled. It was affecting his socialization with others. His aide checked him every 5 minutes and he received an edible treat if his mouth stayed dry. If it was not dry, they worked on wiping his mouth and swallowing, gradually increasing his independence toward this. The intervals eventually increased from 5 minutes to 15 minutes, and eventually his drooling was effectively eliminated (Kay, Harchik, & Luiselli, 2006).
Another article taught 3 adolescents with autism (a 9-year-old and 2, 10-year-olds) social interaction skills and worked with their peers on providing positive social interactions. These students improved not only their social skills, but also demonstrated decreased repetitive motor behaviors (Loftin, Odom, & Lantz, 2007).
Reinforcers can also be given continuously or intermittently. With continuous reinforcement, the reinforcer is given each time the behavior is elicited. Intermittent reinforcers; however, are not given each time, and can be given randomly or after a fixed amount of times the behavior occurs (i.e., after the child says "Mommy" 5 times) (Dillon, n.d).
Use of reinforcers, as shown above, can be a very effective way to elicite and continue to get desired behaviors. Just in the past couple of weeks I used a great example of this in my own home. My kids love bath time, and could stay in there forever. So, I usually assist with the bath and then let them play for awhile. Well, whether I give them 5 or 25 minutes in there, they want to continue to play, and it takes many prompts before they get out. However, last week, my son and daughter got out right away! I immediately praised them and gave them each an M&M. Since then at bath time, they get out right away...hoping for another M&M. Well, they definitely don't get one each time, only when I am feeling generous. So, intermittent positive reinforcement in action!
Use of reinforcers, as shown above, can be a very effective way to elicite and continue to get desired behaviors. Just in the past couple of weeks I used a great example of this in my own home. My kids love bath time, and could stay in there forever. So, I usually assist with the bath and then let them play for awhile. Well, whether I give them 5 or 25 minutes in there, they want to continue to play, and it takes many prompts before they get out. However, last week, my son and daughter got out right away! I immediately praised them and gave them each an M&M. Since then at bath time, they get out right away...hoping for another M&M. Well, they definitely don't get one each time, only when I am feeling generous. So, intermittent positive reinforcement in action!
*Amy has also provided us with an excellent reinforcer survey. You will definitely want to check it out and print off a copy to keep for your records! It's a very comprehensive reinforcer survey, including social reinforcers, food items, objects, etc. It's under Learning Modules > Relating to Other Articles > Reinforcer Survey from CARES
I don't quite understand why the references are at the top...they were on the bottom when I wrote it! If anyone knows why it did this and how to fix it for the future, I'd appreciate the hints! Once again...should I say how much I love computers! :)
ReplyDeleteHI, Ann -- if you want to email me within the course your blog username and password, I can look at the post to see what happened.. I also noted we have to click "read more" to see your post - not sure why?
ReplyDeleteAnyway, with respect to your content:
1) Both article examples were really interesting. I especially found it interesting that the repetetive behaviors decreased (i presume they mean self stim motor behaviors?) when social skills increased. It makes me wonder about the recruitment of motor stim activities in social settings as a result of sympathetic nervous system activation due to the "stress" of socializing. And when "stress" is reduced through skills of socializing, do the motor self stim behaviors reduce? very interesting - makes sense.
2) I giggle at the bath example. Our son, who is 3, was and still is at times hard to get out of the bath... and also working on potty... When we find a reenforcement that is meaningful, he totally keeps asking for it... And then I feel like the "mean guy" who doesn't give it every time! LOL. But it is incredible how smart (and strong at manipulative attempts) kids are?
3) Anne found that survey for us all.. THANKs for directing your peers to it -- we put so much supplemental info on the course, it's great to have each of you point out resources there, as well.
Thanks for your post!
Amy
Hi Ann!
ReplyDeleteI am wondering why decreasing a homework assignment is a negative reinforcer? I guess because they are "taking away" something? Sounds like a positive to me. I guess I think of negative = taking away a want (ie. my teenagers cell phone!), so in that instance could the negative would be to GIVE an extra homework assignment if the behavior at the assembly was not acceptable? Is negative always taking away whether its desired or not, and therfore a positive reinforcer is always something gained even if it's more homework?
Thinking of my own kids, I think it's interesting how individuals respond differently. One child works well if given positive and also negative reinforcement. Not are other child! If we try to encourage a particular behavior by using a negative reinforcer she will dig in her heels and not respond!
Enjoyed your post and the great music:)
Elaine
Oh, thank you so much Anne for the survey that is online. I realized after I had already posted my blog that I put "Amy" instead of Amy and Anne, so I apologize for leaving you out there! It is a great survey!
ReplyDeleteI will email you soon to give you my log-in info. I too, noticed that you have to click on read more to see my blog. The font and size was also different in some areas, and I had put that I wanted it to be all the same font and size. Who knows!?
Elaine,
ReplyDeleteIt can be a little confusing. You are right, negative and positive reinforcers are BOTH meant to increase a desired behavior. The examples you gave would then be considered punishment. So, if you think of the example with the cell phone...positive reinforcement would be getting to keep a cell phone and use it when they are behaving appropriately (for example, no fighting with siblings). However, when they do fight with a sibling, and you take the cell phone away, it would be their punishment.
Some other examples of negative reinforcement that I read about would be the hitting of a Big Mac switch to stop an "annoying" sound. You are getting the behavior you want (hitting the switch), and the annoying noise to the student is taken away.
Hope this helps clear it up a bit.
Thanks Ann! I thought I undersood positive and negative behavior but had it a bit wrong! Thanks for straighting me out- I've got it now:) Elaine
ReplyDeleteAnn,
ReplyDeleteI have come back to your blog to listen to that song at least four times. I think it’s working as a positive reinforcer for me ! Beautiful song.
Re positive/negative reinforcers I recently rewarded my teenager with $50 if he got through a whole month without a single missing homework assignment. He did it and earned the reward. But having proved he could do it I threw in a negative reinforcer and said I would take back $5 for any further assignments he missed. It has worked so far because he does not want to lose any of the money he earned and thankfully I don't have to pay out more!
Thank you for the information about the reinforcer study.
Thanks for clarifying positive and negative reinforcers. I feel people use this terminology for many different reasons. I used to think negative reinforcement is when you reinforce a negative behavior. Audra
ReplyDeleteCatherine,
ReplyDeleteGreat strategy! I'm going to have to keep that one in my memory bank for future reference!
Glad you liked the music!
Amy,
ReplyDeleteI was just doing some further research and found that children with autism who engaged in repetitive behaviors after they were negatively excited showed a decrease in their heart rate. It does make sense that if they are not "stressed" by social interactions with peers, those self-stimulatory behaviors may not be needed to soothe themselves.